The parish’s story is tightly interwoven with the history of the founding family of our community. James Ingersoll, the youngest son of Oxford Village’s founding father, Thomas, deeded a parcel of land to allow the construction of this first church building. The Annual Vestry minutes of 1847 indicate that James Ingersoll was one of the church wardens. By 1864, the original structure was in poor repair and the parish was in danger of closing down completely. But one week after the Bishop’s visit, Thomas Brown, a very successful and influential member of the Ingersoll community, gathered support for a forward looking idea at such a difficult time. He proposed that a Building Committee remove the wood frame church and erect in its place “a good permanent brick building, thereby saving a large outlay in repairs on this [building] which would be necessary in order to make it comfortable”. And so, a new phase began in the life of the St. James’ parish and the existing building that many generations have grown to love and appreciate was finally put in place by 1869. Yet, it wasn’t until all construction debts had been paid, that the parish went from “missionary” status to a “full-fledged” status on November 1, 1876. 

The addition of the Parish Hall in 1930 allowed the parish to open its doors wider.

Many groups were welcomed into the parish as part of St. James’ outreach initiatives. The story of St. James', similar to the histories of many small town churches, reflects the high and lows, the peaks and valleys of the many eras of local and national and international history. As Ingersoll, the town, grew so did our presence in the community. Even though we may have evolved from a “pioneer” existence to a more sophisticated 21^st century state, our faith has remained solidly in place.

In 2020, our church building was sold to a private developer. After much conversation, discussion and voting by Vestry from 2016 to 2019 it was decided that the size of our buildings were too large and too costly to be maintained by the size of our congregation. The Diocese of Huron approved the sale and consequently the parish is on the move again to find a smaller more economic property.

From 2019 to 2025 we rented space from the First Baptist Church for our administrative office and meeting rooms. We also rented the Ingersoll Masonic Hall every Sunday so we had a constant location to hold our Sunday worship services. Thanks to both these groups for accommodating us as we moved forward to relocate to a new location.

This situation changed in November 2025 with the opening of our new property, 130 Thames St. South Ingersoll. As of June 30, 2023 the Diocese of Huron owned this downtown property and tasked our St. James’ congregation with carrying out our vision. We are happy to announce that our long journey has come to an end to relocate. We have done it! Our official consecration of our building took place on Sunday November 2nd, 2025 with The Right Reverend R. Todd Townshend, the Bishop of Huron leading us in a Celebration of Consecration. We welcome everyone to our new church home.

No matter what the financial or physical obstacles have been in the past, present or the future,

St. James’ parishioners maintain their desire to be open and inviting Christians worshiping and ministering through the Anglican values in our local community and beyond.

St. James' Church on Oxford Street - Worship services were held here from 1869 - 2019

Architectural Drawings of 130 Thames St. S